Call it WiX v2 "SP1".

At the beginning of the year we declared the WiX v2 toolset stable. It was a great feeling to finally have something we could point people to when they asked for a WiX toolset that was under constant development. Back then I noted that we would release new drops of WiX v2 when bad enough bugs or big enough changes showed up to warrant it. Three things have come up:

1. MSI 4.5 - rumor has it that MSI 4.5 will be released soon. We have all of the new functionality provided in MSI 4.5 already in WiX v3 so it will just be a matter of porting those changes back to WiX v2.

2. MergeMod.dll - the latest version of mergemod.dll has a nasty bug in it that remained dormant until recently. Bob tracked down the issue and confirmed the bug with the Windows Installer team. We downgraded mergemod.dll in WiX v3 to an older version that doesn't have the bug. Unfortunately, we recently realized that WiX v2 has the same broken version of mergemod.dll so we'll release an update for that.

3. SQL CustomAction - SFBUG:1653864 tracked a rather subtle bug that was fixed a little while ago. That fix has been ported to WiX v2 and will be in the next release.

We started off by jokingly calling this next release of WiX v2 "SP1". The name is starting to stick so I expect we'll stick with it.  The version number will still be "2.0" (with some build number higher than "6400.0").

Just a heads up for those of you who are currently running WiX v2. We'll have a release candidate for WiX v2 "SP1" in the next month or so and would greatly appreciate it everyone gives it a good run through the paces. More information will be posted here and on the WiX web site soon.

 

posted @ Sunday, June 01, 2008 10:59 PM

Print

Comments on this entry:

 re: Call it WiX v2 "SP1".

Left by Reggie at 6/2/2008 5:20 AM

Please don't! There is no difference between a unstable wix v2 sp1 and a wix v3 except it is just confusing. (v2 has been stable and now suddenly it's not). Projects are served better with a faster release cycle with simple versioning (not SP1 nonsense like Windows).

A good rule of thumb is any release that takes longer than 2 months to stabilize and release has too many features in it. Any "large" features should be released in preview drops out-of-band and then rolled into a regular release when they are stable.

Please don't apply Windows-style versioning to this fine open source project.

# re: Call it WiX v2 "SP1".

Left by Albert van Peppen at 6/7/2008 12:02 PM

Why not just v2.1?
Sounds better to me and is easier to check inside your wix script I think ;)

Your comment:



 (will not be displayed)


 
 
 
Please add 6 and 6 and type the answer here:
 

Live Comment Preview: